Insights · Hiring a CFO

Fractional CFO vs controller vs bookkeeper: who do you need?

Leather ledger, a laptop with charts and a notebook on a desk

SHORT ANSWER

A bookkeeper records your transactions. A controller makes sure those records are accurate and turns them into reliable monthly reports. A CFO uses those reports to plan the future: cash, pricing, growth and financing. Most growing businesses need all three jobs done, but not all three as full time hires.

The three roles side by side

BOOKKEEPERCONTROLLERCFO
FocusDaily transactionsAccuracy and reportingPlanning and strategy
Time viewThis weekLast monthNext 3 to 36 months
Typical tasksBills, invoicing, bank feeds, payroll entriesMonth end close, reconciliations, statements, controlsForecasts, budgets, pricing, financing, big decisions
AnswersWhat came in and went out?Are these numbers right?What should we do next?
Fractional optionOutsourced bookkeeping firmFractional controllerFractional CFO

When you need a bookkeeper

If nobody is recording transactions consistently, start here. Nothing else works without it. Most businesses under $1M in revenue need a good bookkeeper and a CPA, and not much more.

When you need a controller

You need controller level support when reports arrive late, change after the fact, or don’t match what is in the bank. It is also the right step when a lender, investor or buyer is about to look closely at your books.

When you need a CFO

You need a CFO when the books are sound but you still can’t answer questions like “Can we afford this hire?”, “Which customers actually make us money?” or “How much cash will we have in August?” That is planning work, and it is what a CFO does.

Can one person do both?

Often, yes. Many fractional CFOs, including me, work at both levels: cleaning up and running the controller work first, then moving into planning once the foundation is solid. For a business between $1M and $15M, that combined role is usually the most cost effective setup.

A simple way to decide

  • Books behind or unreliable: controller first
  • Books clean, but decisions still feel like guesses: CFO
  • Both: a fractional CFO who also covers controller work

Not sure which one you need? I will tell you honestly, even if the answer is “just a better bookkeeper.”

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is a controller the same as an accountant?

A controller is a senior accountant who owns the accuracy of the books and the monthly close.

Can a fractional CFO replace my bookkeeper?

No. A bookkeeper records daily transactions. A fractional CFO uses those records to plan ahead. Most businesses need both.

What does a fractional controller cost?

It depends on how much cleanup and monthly work you need. Most businesses pay a monthly retainer, and every engagement starts with a free call and a written scope.

Not sure which one you need?

Book a free 30 minute call. No pressure and no pitch.